CIVIL DISCOVERY & PRIVILEGE LAW
Discovery Referee,  Electronic Data Discovery,   Discovery of Evidence,  Case Law Outlines & Summaries,  Practice Tips,  Recent Legal Developments,  Sanctions, Legal Education,  Experts, Depositions, Statutes,  Document Production,  Attorney Client Privilege,    Work Product,  Interrogatories,  Admissions,  Medical Examinations,    Discovery Court Rules, Ethics, California Discovery Act, ....
                                                            Getting Results with Cost Effective Discovery
HOME

Site Navigation


SITE INFORMATION           Contact Richard E. Best 
This site was posted to the present location in November 1999. The legal content is based on the Civil Discovery Case Law Outlines first prepared by Commissioner Richard E. Best in 1980 and used in continuing legal eduction programs since then. The balance of the site is the response to requests and  suggestions to inform litigants of practice and procedures related to civil discovery. Your constructive comments are much appreciated and will assist in the continuing development of this site.

RICHARD E. BEST,    Discovery Referee, Consultant & Private Judge   Best@Justice.com

Education

A.B., Indiana University, College of Arts & Sciences, Economics, 1965
LL.B, Columbia University, School of Law, 1968

Admitted to practice law [retired /inactive]

New York, 1968
California, 1971

Private court appointed Discovery Referee, Private Judge
Adjunct Professor of Law, Golden Gate University,
Observer, The Sedona Conference, Working Group on Best Practices, Electronic Document Retention & Production
Advisor, California State Bar,  Executive Committee, Litigation Section
2005 recipient Electronic Evidence Thought Leading Scholar Award
Court Commissioner, San Francisco Superior Court, 1974-March 15, 2003
Discovery and other law & motion matters heard since 1974

Member, Civil & Small Claims Advisory Committee to California Judicial Council, 1999-2001
Chair, Discovery Subcommittee, 2000
, 2001

Proposed, drafted, and worked to enact legislation on civil procedure and evidence including legislation for use of technology in civil litigation and discovery, Code of Civil Procedure §§2017(e) & 2025(h) enacted in 2001 and effective 2002
Proposed, drafted, and worked for adoption of California Rules of Court and legislation on civil procedure and evidence including Rules 335, 341, E.C. §915, CCP §2026
Formed lawyers committee on employment law form interrogatories which led to adoption by the Judicial Counsel of form interrogatories for employment law litigation
Formed lawyers committee to evaluate need for special rules and discovery relating to electronic data and documents

Proposed California E-Discovery Rule submitted to Judicial Council in 2004
Contributor to continuing legal publications on civil procedure, probate, and conservatorships published by Continuing Education of the Bar, The Rutter Group, Nolo Press
, BNA, CJER Tech Journal, Pike & Fischer, California Center for Judicial Education and Research; Contributing Editor, Civil Procedure Before Trial, The Rutter Group; Advisory Board, Digital Discovery & e-Evidence, Pike & Fischer,Inc.


Recent Publications

"E-Discovery for the Routine Case", ABTL Report, Volume 16, Number 3, Summer 2007. Association of Business Trial Lawyers of Northern California

"E-Discovery: What Courts Expect of Counsel";   Judge's Prospective:, California Civil Litigation Reporter; October 2006; Volume 28, No.5;
Regents of the University of California, Continuing Education of the Bar
"Taming the Discovery Monster"  
California Litigation: The Journal of the Litigation Section, State Bar of California,  November, 2005
"E-Discovery Basics"  California Litigation: The Journal of the Litigation Section, State Bar of California,  August 2005
"Making E-Discovery Work"  Oregon Association of Defense Counsel,  June 2004
"How, When & Why to Use a Discovery Referee",  Pike & Fischer, Digital Discovery & e-Evidence, Vol.5,No.1, January, 2005
"Why Discover Electronic Documents"  Association of Defense Counsel, Northern Calif &Nevada (2003)
"The Need for Electronic Discovery Rules",
Modern Practice, Findlaw(2002)
California E-Discovery Legislation
Digital Discovery & e-Evidence Pike & Fischer,Inc. (2002)
"New Authority for Implementing Technology in Discovery" Tech Guide for California Courts, Vol.3, No.3, California Judicial Education & Research (Winter, 2002)
"Discovery Of Electronic Data & Documents"
Selected Civil Law Topics (CJER 2001)
"Discovery Case Outline"
Discovery Planning: Strategies, Tools & Tactics, (CEB 2001)
"A Web Site for Every Court",
Tech Guide for California Courts, Vol.2, No.1(CJER,2000)
"Discovery of Electronic Data & Documents",
Discovery & Admissibility of Electronic Evidence (CEB 1999)

2006 Continuing Legal Education
E-discovery Ethics
San Francisco, 
December  , 2006
Practicing Law Institute

Electronic Discovery
Pasadena, Ca. October 2006
Continuing Judicial Studies Program; California Administrative Office of the Courts

E-Discovery Sanctions, Spoliation and Malpractice:  Are Lawyers Meeting the Standard of Care?
February, 2006;  Continuing Education of the Bar

E-discovery Ethics
San Francisco;  June 2006
Continuing Education of the Bar


2005 Continuing Legal Education

Electronic Discovery Guidance for Corporate Counsel
Ethical Issue in Electronic Discovery
San Francisco, December 16, 2005
Practicing Law Institute

Annual Electronic Discovery & Records Management Seminar
December 8-9, 2005
San Francisco

Basic Electronic Discovery
SF Bar Assn., Litigation Section
November 11,  2005
San Francisco

TAKING EFFECTIVE DEPOSITIONS
June 7, 2005;  9:00-4:30
with  Mary Alexander, Frank Pitre, Dave McClean, Neill McCarthy
Crown Plaza,  San Fraancisco
Lorman Education Services

How, When and Why to Use a Discovery Referee
with Craig Ball
May 4, 2005
webcast   on Discovery  Resources, Fios Inc.

Judicial Perspectives on Electronic Discover
with Hon. David J. Waxee, Federal District Court, Kansas; Kenneth J. Withers, Federal Judicial Center
April 28, 2005
Kroll Ontrack Online Seminar

Electronic Discovery & Digital Evidence Institute
State Bar of Texas, Litigation Section
Hotel Derek,  April 6, 2005
Houston, Texas

Glasser Legal Works Legal Technology Show
March 17 & 18
Hyatt
San Francisco


Electronic Discovery in California:  Legal Strategies &  Best Practices
January 27, 2005
sponsored by the Lorman Education Services
San Francisco



2004 Continuing Legal Education

Annual Electronic Discovery & Records Management Seminar
December 9-10, 2004
San Francisco

Electronic Discovery Guidance for Corporate Counsel
Ethical Issue in Electronic Discovery
San Francisco, November 19,2004
Practicing Law Institute

E-Discovery  Seminar
Keynote Address
Seattle, Washington
October 28, 2004
Applied Discovery

Discovery of Electronic Data & Documents
California Judges Association
October 9, 2004
Monterey, Cal

New Realities in E-Discovery: Lessons Learned and Practical Applications
"The Digital “Sword of Damocles” - How to Address the Spoliation of Electronic Evidence"
Georgetown Law Center, October 7-8, 2004.
Washington, D.C.

The Impact of the New Federal Rules of Civil Discovery on E-discovery
Las Vegas , Nevada  September 23-24
Keynote address: Why the Rules are Needed
Moderator: Ethical Issues in E-Discovery

Educating the Judge on E-Discovery Issues
Oregon Association of Defense Counsel
June 18, 2004,    Sun River
Redmond, Oregon

TAKING EFFECTIVE DEPOSITIONS
June 2, 2004;  9:00-4:30
Richard Best, Mary Alexander, Frank Pitre, Dave McClean
San Fraancisco
Lorman Education Services

Glasser Legal Works Legal Technology Show
April 15-16, 2004
Panels

"Electronic Discovery from the Inside Out:  Practice & Trends"
"Understanding and Using the New E-Discovery Rules"
"Educating the Judge: Crossing the Digital Divide"
"Controlling the Cost of E-Discovery"

Hyatt Regency Hotel
San Francisco, Ca.


Strategic Tips for Successfully Propounding & Opposing Written Discovery
Sacramento February 28, 2004  1:15-4-:30
Red Lion Hotel • 1401 Arden Way
San Francisco March 13, 2004; 1:15 pm to 4:30 pm
PLI California Center • Conference Room • 685 Market Street - Suite 100
Sponsored by Calif. Continuing Education of the Bar

Conferences of Chief Justices
National Center for State Courts 
Chief  Justice Randall T. Shepard, Indiana Supreme Court
Mary Alexander, Tom Allman, Ken Withers, Virginia Llewellyn, Judge Fern Smith
January 20, 2004
San Francisco

Sedgwick, Detert, Moran & Arnold
January 9, 2004
San Francisco, Ca


2003 Continuing Legal Education
presented in part by Richard E. Best

Electronic Discovery In Employment Law
November 21, 2003
Walnut Creek Marriott
Conta Costa MCLE Spectacular

"Discovery in Fiduciary Litigation for Trusts & Estates Lawyers"
Dom Campisi (SF), Mary Gillick (Luce Forward, San Diego), Richard E.Best
Saturday, November 15, 2003, 1:15 to 4:30 p.m.
San Francisco, Crowne Plaza Hotel
CEB Continuin Education of the Bar


October 30, 2003; 5:30
Arrivederci Cafe; 11 G Street, San Rafael
Marin Trial Lawyers

Recent Develop[ments in Electronic Discovery
American Bar Assoc.

Robert Phillips, John Pendleton
August 11, 2003; 9:00-12:00
San Francisco, Ca.


TAKING EFFECTIVE DEPOSITIONS
June 25 2003
Richard Best, Mary Alexander, Frank Pitre, Jack Slobodin
San Fraancisco
Lorman Education Services

"Electronic Discovery: What You Need to Know Now."
June 5, 2003, 8:30 - 12:00
Geoffrey Howard, Rachael Chatman, Rob Shives
Grand Hyatt Hotel
San Francisco

June 3, 2003
Los Angeles
Kroll Ontrack Inc.


Association of Defense Counsel
Steve Brower, Magistrate Judge Valerie Cooke, Comm'n. Wes Ayers
Reno, Nev.
May 16, 2003

Legalworks Seminars
Getting Technology Right: 6th Annual Technology Answer Show

Strategies & Best Practices of Cost Effective Electronic Discovery [Tuesday]
Multimedia Depositions, Remote Arguments [Wednesday]
Demystifying Electronic Discovery,Effective Recods Management & Risk Control [Wed. Breakfast Workshop]

April 22-23, 2003
San Francisco Hilton Hotel
Glasser Legal Works


Litigation Section, San Francisco Bar Assn
SF Bar Assn.
April 10, 2003; 12:00 noon luncheon
Commissioner Everett A. Hewlett Jr., William Lee and Richard Best
Civil Discovery in San Francisco


CLE Discovery Program
Hancock, Rothert & Bunshoft
4 Embarcadero Center 3rd floor
San Francisco, Calif.
April 3, 2003, 5:00PM


Effective Use of Technology in the Litigation Practice
Friday, March 21, 2003
San Francisco, California
Grand Hyatt San Francisco
http://www.theseminargroup.net/htmls/seminars/03disca/index.htm

Electronic Evidence Discovery
School of Law
Univ.Missouri Kansas City
Kansas City, Mo
March 7, 2003

2002 Continuing Legal Education
presented in part by Richard E. Best

Electronic Discovery
Association of Defense Counsel Annual Meeting
December 5, 2002
San Francisco, California

Sixth Annual Electronic Discovery & Records Management Seminar
December 5, 2002 San Francisco
Glasser Legal Works

Discovery of Electronic Data & Documents
Assigned Judges Continuing Education
October 18, 2002
San Mateo, Calif.
California Center for Judicial Education and Research


EFFECTIVE USE OF TECHNOLOGY IN LITIGATION
Keynote address
Panelist on ethics issues
September 26-27,2002
Seattle, Washington

TAKING EFFECTIVE DEPOSITIONS
June 2002
Richard Best, Mary Alexander, Frank Pitre, Jack Slobodin
San Fraancisco
Lorman Education Services

FUNDAMENTALS OF PRETRIAL PRACTICE
April 19 & 20; 12 hour CEB program
San Francisco,
Continuing Education of the Bar

BNA Litigation Forum--Electronic Discovery: Best Practices and Evolving Law
Moderator of panel on privilege issues
San Francisco; April 4 & 5 2002

Essentials of Electronic Discovery
Moderator of 5 panels
March 2002
Los Angeles San Diego San Francisco Sacramento Orange County
Continuing Education of the Bar


San Francisco Discovery Practice
Barristers Club, San francisco Bar
February, 2002


Electronic Discovery: Tips Tactics and Technology
Keynote: "Making E-Discovery Work: rules, referees and reason"
February 5, 2002
Los Angeles
Ontrack


2001 Continuing Legal Education
presented in part by Richard E. Best

Fifth Annual Electronic Discovery & Records Management Seminar
November 30, 2001 San Francisco
Glasser Legal Works


Retired Judges
Electronic Discovery
San Diego, November 2
California Center for Judicial Education and Research

Latest Deposition Techniques
October 19; November 14, 2001
San Francisco Bar Association

Electronic Discovery and Other Prickly Discovery Issues
CELA Annual Conference
San Francisco; October 27, 2001
California Employment Lawyers Association


BNA Litigation Forum--Electronic Discovery: Best Practices and Evolving Law
San Francisco; October 15 &16
BNA; Pike & Fisher

Continuing Judicial Studies Program,
Electronic Discovery
San Diego, August 5
California Center for Judicial Education and Research

DISCOVERY: STRATEGIES & TACTICS FOR SUCCESS
San Francisco Sacramento; July 2001
Continuing Education of the Bar


TAKING EFFECTIVE DEPOSITIONS
June 2001
Richard Best, Mary Alexander, Frank Pitre, Jack Slobodin
San Fraancisco
Lorman Education Services


April 24,25, 2001
5th Annual Technology Answer Show
San Francisco
Glasser Legal Works


Electronic Discovery
Civil Law and Procedure Institute
Monterey, January 27, 2001
California Center for Judicial Education and Research


1999 CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION
presented in part by Richard E. Best

November 1999; 12 hour CEB program
FUNDAMENTALS OF PRETRIAL PRACTICE
San Francisco, November 5&6

July 10 & 24, 1999
STRATEGIC TIPS FOR SUCCESSFULLY PROPOUNDING & OPPOSING WRITTEN DISCOVERY, CEB
Sacramento & San Francisco(moderator)

June 25, 1999
TAKING EFFECTIVE DEPOSITIONS
Richard Best, Mary Alexander, Raoul Kennedy, Frank Pitre, Jack Slobodin

Lorman Education Services
San Fraancisco


May 7,8,15,21,22, 1999; Moderator
San Diego, San Francisco, Century City, Anaheim, Sacramento
DISCOVERY & ADMISSIBILITY OF ELECTRONIC EVIDENCE
CEB

March 26, 1999; San Francisco
COMPUTER DISCOVERY & ELECTRONIC DATA RETENTION RISK CONTROL
Glasser Legal Works

March 3 & 27, 1999 Arne Wercheck, Arthur J. Casey, Richard Best
DISCOVERY: STRATEGIES & TACTICS FOR SUCCESS
San Francisco(moderator) & Sacramento

September 15, 1998; Everet A. Hewlett, Barbara Lawless & Richard Best
Queen's Bench ABC's of Law
San Francisco Courthouse

SITE NAVIGATION

DISCOVERY
HOME
Case
Outlines
DISCOVERY
ACT
New
Matter
CAL. LEGAL
RESOURCES

DISCOVERY
REFEREE

FEDERAL
RESOURCES

B IO & SITE
INFO
CONTACT
E-discovery
Deposition
Interrogatory
Document
Admission
Experts
Med.Exam Sanctions Meet & Confer Disc.Cutoff Referee
Basic Disc
E-discovery
Atty.- Client
Work Product
Privacy
Phys-Patient
Med.Qual.Rev
Reporter Priv
Official Info
Tax Return